We, the Media Wannabes…
January 24th, 2012 by Keith Burton
One of my favorite books on Web 2.0 is The Cult of the Amateur by Andrew Keen (http://www.ajkeen.com/bio/), who decries today’s self-broadcasting culture, where “amateurism is celebrated and anyone with an opinion, however ill-informed, can publish a blog, post a video on YouTube or change an entry on Wikipedia…” In this brave new world,” Keen says, “the distinction between trained expert and uninformed amateur becomes dangerously blurred.”
That was 2007. Fast forward to January 2012, when a Cook County, Illinois, jury ruled that a California blog, TechnoBuffalo, doesn’t qualify as a reporter and ordered it turn over information on a tipster who leaked details about Motorola’s Droid Bionic cellphone. TechnoBuffalo purports to have a million monthly readers and argued that it’s published under journalist shield laws in Illinois and California. An Illinois printing house, Johns-Byrne Co., brought a petition against TechnoBuffalo seeking the name of the individual who leaked images from the user’s guide to the Droid Bionic. Johns-Byrne allegedly wants to pursue an action against the tipster, who it believes may be a Johns-Byrne employee.
In a ruling that would probably bring a knowing smile from Keen, Judge Michael Painter ruled that the legal position argued by TechnoBuffalo is “a fast-moving issue facing courts everywhere.” He said TechnoBuffalo is not a news medium and should not be afforded protection under Illinois shield laws. In Cult, Keen himself wrote of citizen journalists: “The simple ownership of a computer and an Internet connection doesn’t transform one into a serious journalist any more than having access to a kitchen makes one into a serious cook. But millions of amateur journalists think that it does.” In a past study by the Pew Internet and American Life Project, millions of American bloggers say they consider their online “work” to be a form of journalism. Keen said that translates into millions of unskilled, untrained, unpaid, unknown “journalists” who are “wannabe Matt Drudges.”
Drudge himself once said that “the Net gives as much voice to a thirteen-year-old computer geek like me as to a CEO or Speaker of the House.”
“We all became equal” is the catch phrase, Keen says, of citizen journalist movement. We, the media wannabes.
Watch this space. The issue of protecting blogger sources under the law promises to raise its head again soon. How it will affect our work as internal communicators remains to be seen.






